The duality of consciousness
Machine-translated from Russian. Show original
Idea maturity
60%Disclosed in 3 of 3 basic facets. Strong sides — essence, implementation, and value;
Parts of the idea
Consciousness is dual: on the one hand it's nonlocal, like the higher circuits in the Leary-Wilson model; on the other hand it's the same in all people, because it's built on shared processes described by mathematics, psychology, and neuroscience.
To move forward, you need to state both sides so they can be tested: what exactly in consciousness is the same for everyone, and what its nonlocality means. The first part can be checked against data from neuroscience and psychology; the second remains a matter for reflection for now.
People who ponder the nature of consciousness: the idea brings two usually opposed views into one frame and offers a reason to think about a question that will most likely stay open for a long time.
The non-locality of consciousness is a nod to the "non-local quantum circuit" of Leary-Wilson, from Timothy Leary's eight-circuit model of consciousness, developed further by Robert Anton Wilson. In this model, consciousness is divided into eight "circuits" (four "terrestrial" ones for survival and four "cosmic" ones for evolution), where the higher circuits (5–8) imply non-local, quantum or even post-physical processes, like collective intelligence or manifesting reality on a meta level. That makes consciousness "non-local": not strictly tied to the brain, but spreading through quantum fields or information structures.
You can read more about the non-locality of consciousness in Dan Brown's "The Secret of Secrets".
On the other hand, consciousness is a universal template, the same for everyone, because it's built on shared processes: neural networks (neurobiology), cognitive models (psychology) and algorithms (mathematics). For example, Ken Wilber's integral theory or neurocomputational models (as in AI research) stress that the basic patterns (perception, attention, self-reflection) recur in all people, regardless of culture.
For the foreseeable future, the proposed duality of consciousness is even more unresolvable than the wave-particle duality of elementary particles.
In cognitive science, the universality of consciousness is backed by the idea of the modularity of mind (Jerry Fodor) and embodied cognition, where basic processes (perception, attention, memory and decision-making) are built on shared neural and algorithmic patterns, described by mathematics (Bayesian models of predictive coding) and psychology (Piaget's stages of development).
- Neurobiological foundations: Research shows that the same networks activate in all people (the default mode network for self-reflection or the salience network for attention), regardless of culture. This supports the notion of "the same processes": consciousness is an emergent property of universal computations, as in AI models (neural networks imitating human cognition).
- The psychological angle: Gardner's theory of multiple intelligences or Chomsky's cognitive universals (in linguistics) stress that the mind's basic "code" (for example, hierarchical information processing) is the same for everyone, which makes consciousness a "universal template".
Cognitive science adds some intrigue through the concepts of the extended mind (Andy Clark and David Chalmers, 1998) and distributed cognition (Edwin Hutchins). Consciousness isn't "locked" in the skull: it spreads out into the environment, tools and even social networks. That's "non-locality" in the cognitive sense.
The idea isn't as batshit as the idea of the duality of the Earth (geoid or flat?), but for most ordinary folks it's far more unknowable (just getting yourself into space won't cut it).
Discussion nothing yet
Sign in — to join the discussion